Tag Archives: Invasive Species

The Next Invasive SpeciesThreat to Lake Champlain

This report from the Albany Times-Union looks at the asian clam, an invasive species that has established itself in Lake George. Officials there fear they are losing the battle to the asian clam and discuss the impact that this will have on Lake George.

Since Lake George empties into Lake Champlain via the Lachute River in Ticonderoga, the asian clam seems destined to be the next invasive threat to Lake Champlain.

Invasive clams appear to be winning in Lake George

Lake George is now infested by a species that could reduce tourism, business activity and property values

By Brian Nearing     Updated 7:18 a.m., Monday, September 24, 2012

A map showing where on the lake Asian clams have been found is seen on a screen during a meeting of the Asian Clam task force on Thursday, Sept. 20, 2012 at The Lake George Association headquarters in Lake George, NY.  (Paul Buckowski / Times Union) Photo: Paul Buckowski

A map showing where on the lake Asian clams have been found is seen on a screen during a meeting of the Asian Clam task force on Thursday, Sept. 20, 2012 at The Lake George Association headquarters in Lake George, NY. (Paul Buckowski / Times Union)

LAKE GEORGE — Two years and $1.5 million later, efforts to rid the Queen of American Lakes of a harmful invasive clam seem to have failed. With fast-breeding Asian clams now spreading, the best hope is to keep their numbers in check — a costly fight that could last for years — and wait for a breakthrough eradication technique.

That was the grim assessment last week by the lake’s Asian Clam Rapid Response Task Force, a group of state, municipal, civic and environmental groups that has spearheaded work to eradicate clam beds by smothering them under weighted underwater mats.

The setback in the battle against the clams comes as the Lake George Park Commission, the state agency in charge of protecting the lake, also is racing to create a plan to reduce the risk of future aquatic invaders being brought in by recreational boaters, who likely transported the Asian clam from other infested water bodies in bilge water or bait wells. Widespread clam infestation in the lake could mean diminished tourism, business and property values. Clams have already caused some of those problems in Lake Tahoe, on the California-Nevada border, where beds now cover several hundred acres.

Thriving in sunlit, shallow, sandy lake bottoms, the tiny mollusks pose a major threat to the lake’s legendary gin-clear waters, which drive vibrant tourism, boating and recreational fishing industries.

Large clam colonies can foul beach waters because their excretions fuel massive algae blooms. Fast-breeding hermaphrodites, clams can quickly multiply into the millions and, when dead, wash up on beaches, where their razor-sharp shells make walking dangerous.

In Lake George, two years’ use of underwater mats — as well as underwater suctioning — in four places totaling 15 acres along the lake’s southwest side from the village of Lake George near Million Dollar Beach to the town of Bolton has not wiped out the clams, which remain entrenched and in some cases are even more numerous, according to surveys done this month.

A view of some Asian clams in a container at the Lake George Association headquarters seen here on Thursday, Sept. 20, 2012 in Lake George, NY. (Paul Buckowski / Times Union)

Just this month, Asian clams were found in four new spots, including for the first time on the lake’s eastern and northern shores in Shelving Rock Bay in Fort Ann and Lake Forest in Hague, respectively. The other new clam colonies were found near the Golden Sands resort near Diamond Point and Route 9L near Paulist Fathers Road. Those combined spots total at least two acres.

“We have had disappointing results with some of our mats. Eradication of the clams now seems clearly out of the question.

It is technologically beyond our ability to eliminate it,” said Dave Wick, executive director of the park commission and a task force member, on Thursday. Lake George is the only lake in the state with its own state agency.

“We have to shift from a strategy of eradication to one of long-term management of the clam,” said Walter Lender, director of the Lake George Association, a not-for-profit group that has helped fund the work so far.

Over concerns about future invasives, the commission is considering a mandatory inspection system for the thousands of boats that are launched on the lake each summer. A plan will likely be decided upon this fall.

Wick said it would likely cost $1 million to put down mats this fall on all eight known infested locations — but the task force now has only about $140,000 available.

That will be devoted to putting mats at the four new locations, which are relatively small.

“What is at risk is the economy and the ecology of the lake, upon which the economy is based,” said Alexander Gabriels, a task force member and former Bolton town supervisor.

The town-owned Norowal Marina on Route 9N is one of the lake’s busiest public boat launches, as well as one of the original infested areas. Clams remain there in high numbers despite two years of using mats and are just 200 yards south of the town’s Veterans Beach. Norowal Marina also is directly across the lake from Shelving Rock Bay, a popular site that each summer draws hundreds of boaters for Log Bay Day.

A view looking north from the south end of Lake George on Thursday, Sept. 20, 2012 in Lake George, NY. (Paul Buckowski / Times Union)

“We have paid for this all so far with public dollars,” said Wick. “We will have to start looking at the million-dollar businesses along the lake.”

Eric Siy, director of the Fund for Lake George, another lake advocacy group, said, “We are in an all-hands-on deck, all-checkbooks-on-the-table situation.”

At the Georgian Resort in the village of Lake George, clam-smothering mats have been used for the last two years without success. The venerable 159-room resort needs a healthy lake, marketing manager Dick Carlson said.”What you don’t want in this business is negative publicity that might encourage people to stay away.”

Carlson said he understands the need to pay for invasive species control, and suggested that Warren County could set aside part of its 4 percent hotel bed tax. “We would have to look into it, but I am sure that we would be able to contribute something toward it,” he said.

Wick said the commission was rebuffed when it sought financial support from the state and the Department of Environmental Conservation. “The state does not have any money for us, at least in the next six months,” he said.

The DEC press office referred questions to Ed Woltman, head of its Bureau of Fisheries, who said he could not speak to state funding issues.

Woltman said the state favors “outreach and education” of recreational boaters on the importance of keeping boats cleaned, drained and dry.

A sign is posted on an information board near a boat launch on the south end of Lake George informs boaters to help prevent the spread of invasive species seen here on Thursday, Sept. 20, 2012 in Lake George, NY. (Paul Buckowski / Times Union)

DEC maintains four public boat launches on the lake – at Mossy Point in Ticonderoga, Million Dollar Beach in Lake George, Rogers Rock in Hague and Northwest Bay in Bolton. Woltman said creating a network of boat-cleaning stations, which use high-pressure hot water to blast away invasives, would be logistically difficult.

In 2009, Lake Tahoe set up a mandatory boat cleaning system, partially supported by federal funds and partially by registration stickers required for boaters.Woltman said the state is concerned about future invasives and wants to see what kind of prevention plan the park commission creates.

Since 2008, volunteers from the Lake George Association have checked more than 24,000 boats being put in or being taken out of the lake, said Emily DeBolt, education director. Of those, 378 boats carried an invasive species.

“Invasive species are on the march. The state needs to pay attention to this,” said Gabriels.

bnearing@timesunion.com • 518-454-5094 • @Bnearing10

Learn more about invasive species > Click here

More about the asian clam

New Weapon to Combat Sea Lamprey in Lake Champlain

New York State officials are very encouraged about the first results from this newest tool in the fight against Lake Champlain’s sea lamprey pests according to this article from the Glens Falls Post-Star.

This specialized boat and sprayer uses sonar to locate lamprey ammocetes, then targets them with a safer and more specific lampricide than has been used in the past; additionally treatment can be performed during windy conditions.

High-tech methods used to kill invasive lampreys

Biologists have a new weapon against a fish-killing pest in Lake Champlain, and initial results have left state officials optimistic it will greatly assist efforts to protect sport fish in the lake.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has purchased a specialized boat equipped with a sprayer that allows fisheries experts to more accurately target areas where sea lamprey young are living, said Bill Schoch, the state Department of Environmental Conservation’s regional fisheries manager.

The boat has side-scanning sonar to allow scientists to find the lamprey young, called ammocetes, the pesticide is designed to kill.

“They can find ammocetes with much better accuracy than before,” Schoch said.

The new boat can also be used in windy conditions that in the past have foiled treatment efforts, Schoch said.

“It treats faster and more accurately and can work in rougher weather,” Schoch said. “It’s a remarkable improvement.”

Calls to the Fish and Wildlife Service office in Burlington, Vt., were not returned last week.

Lampreys are voracious predators, attaching themselves to fish and boring through their scales to consume their blood and bodily fluids.

Treatments targeting them have proven effective in curtailing the population. Fish wound rates have dropped from more than 60 per 100 fish to 15 per 100 fish.

The new boat and equipment were used late last month to treat the Saranac River delta, a major lamprey breeding ground, and the result was hundreds of thousands of dead lamprey young, officials said.

The machine also allows the use of a different pesticide that targets only lampreys. A chemical called Bayluscide was used at the Saranac River delta site, when in the past a different chemical called TFM was used, which was applied by a spreader or pump.

Use of TFM has been controversial because the chemical may kill other organisms.

For now, the new computerized equipment can only be used to treat lake deltas and not tributaries, where other treatments using TFM will continue to be done, Schoch said.

In all, two deltas and five brooks are scheduled to be treated this fall, but treatments have been delayed by low water.

Mount Hope Brook in Whitehall, which feeds South Bay, is scheduled for treatment early next month, while treatment of other tributaries further north and on the Vermont side is set into late October.

Mill Brook in Essex County is the only other tributary in the region scheduled to be treated this year. The Poultney River was treated last year but will not be treated this year.

Mount Hope Brook was scheduled to be treated last year, but the water was too high in the wake of Tropical Storm Irene and other rain events.

Click Here to learn more about Lake Champlain sea lampreys

Sea Lamprey in Lake Champlain

Sea Lamprey

Petromyzon marinus

Adult sea lampreyThe sea lamprey (Petromyzon marinus) is one of four lamprey species found in the Lake Champlain Basin. Lamprey are eel-shaped fish with a skeleton made of cartilage and they belong to a primitive group of jawless fish called Agnathans. Sea lamprey have smooth, scaleless skin and two fins on their back (dorsal fins). The sea lamprey is parasitic; feeding on other fish by using a suction disk mouth filled with small sharp, rasping teeth and a file-like tongue. These are used by the sea lamprey to attach to a fish, puncture its skin, and drain its bodily fluids.

Sea lamprey have a complex life cycle. Their first four years are spent as ammocoetes – a blind worm-like larval stage – in the soft bottom and banks of waters that flow into Lake Champlain. They then transform into the parasitic adult stage and enter the lake to feed on landlocked Atlantic salmon, lake trout ; which they prefer due to their small scales and thin skin – and other fish species. After twelve to twenty months in the lake the adults migrate back into the streams to spawn, after which they die.

.

Lampreys in Lake Champlain

Moderate numbers of sea lampreys were first noted in Lake Champlain in 1929. The sea lamprey has long been considered a non-native invasive species that entered Lake Champlain during the 1800s via the Champlain Canal. Recent genetic studies indicate that the sea lamprey may, in fact, be native to Lake Champlain.

Three other lamprey species are found in the Lake Champlain Basin. Two are non-parasitic, and although the third species is parasitic, it does not seem to have much impact on the Lake Champlain fish community.

Whether or not the sea lamprey is native to Lake Champlain, it has detrimental impacts on the Lake Champlain fisheries, ecosystem, and human residents that are very significant.

.

What Are The Impacts of the Sea Lamprey?

Lake trout with sea lamprey attached.

Sea lamprey have a major detrimental impact on the Lake Champlain fish community, the Lake Champlain Basin ecosystem, the anglers that fish Lake Champlain, and the many people throughout the watershed whose livelihood is directly or indirectly supported by the fishing and tourist industry.

Adult sea lamprey attach to a host fish, rasp and puncture its skin, and drain its body fluids, often killing the host fish. Their preferred hosts are salmon, lake trout and other trout species, however they also feed on other fish species, including lake whitefish, walleye, northern pike, burbot, and lake sturgeon. The lake sturgeon is listed as a threatened species in New York and an endangered species in Vermont and it is likely that sea lamprey are affecting their survival.

Most sea lamprey hosts are native fish species that have been part of the Lake Champlain Basin ecosystem for thousands of years. Additionally many of these fish species are important sport fish, highly prized and sought after by anglers.

Fresh lamprey wound on a fish and the lamprey that was removed from the fish.

Prior to any control measures being taken, catches of lake trout and salmon in Lake Champlain were a fraction of catches in similar lakes, despite intensive stocking efforts. High wounding rates indicated that sea lamprey were having a significant impact on the lake trout and salmon populations, and were preventing the restoration of these native fish species to Lake Champlain.

Studies on the Great Lakes show a 40 to 60 percent mortality rate for fish attacked by sea lamprey. Other studies found that a single sea lamprey can kill 40 or more pounds of fish during its adult life. The abundance of sea lamprey were obviously having significant impacts on Lake Champlain’s fishery and ecosystem.

.

Sea Lamprey Control

Liquid TFM applied to a stream during a lamprey control treatment.Due to the severity of the impacts that sea lamprey have had on the Lake Champlain fishery and ecosystem, and the social and economic impacts on the people who live in the Lake Champlain Basin, it was determined that sea lamprey populations should be controlled. The federal and state governments, the agencies that manage Lake Champlain, the various organizations that are concerned with Lake Champlain and the people who live in the Lake Champlain Basin generally agree that it would be irresponsible not to control the sea lamprey population.

.

.

The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, the Vermont Department of Fish and Wildlife and the United States Fish and Wildlife Service formed a cooperative and began an integrated control program to reduce the sea lamprey population in Lake Champlain to  acceptable levels. This program is not attempting to eliminate the sea lamprey from Lake Champlain, but only to reduce the impacts of sea lamprey on the lake’s fishery and restore balance to the ecosystem.

.

Control Efforts

Bayluscide being distributed from boat during a lamprey control treatment on a delta.Physical methods of control include the use of barriers that prevent adult sea lamprey from migrating up waterways to spawn and traps to capture adult sea lamprey before they can spawn.

However, the most effective form of control has been the treating of tributaries and deltas with lampricides – TFM in tributaries and Bayluscide on deltas. The lampricides target the larval sea lamprey, killing them before they can transform into their parasitic adult form.

It should be noted that after years of study in Lake Champlain, the Great Lakes, and other places where sea lamprey are controlled using lampricides, fisheries managers have concluded that the lampricides have little or no known permanent effect on populations of non-target species present in the treatment areas.

.

Control Program

small map showing the different methods employed to control Lake Champlain sea lamprey with different color codes
(Click on Map to Enlarge)

Evaluation of an eight year experimental sea lamprey control program that took place in Lake Champlain in the 1990s documented significant benefits for fish and anglers. These benefits included decreases in wounding rates on trout and salmon, increases in weight and survival rates of lake trout, increases in angler catch rates of lake trout and a benefit to cost ratio of 3.5 to 1.

At the end of the eight year experimental sea lamprey control program, a limited, three-year interim sea lamprey control program was undertaken from 1998 to 2000. After a thorough environmental review, a long-term sea lamprey control program began in 2002.

Fish sampling programs, salmon returns to fish ladders, angler surveys and sampling of larval sea lamprey are used to measure the effectiveness of the control program. The control program may be expanded to other streams and delta areas if significant sea lamprey populations develop in them.

.

.

Assessments of sea lamprey populations are made before any control measures begin and again afterwards to determine the effectiveness of the controls. Field staff, using a variety of capture methods, sample both adult and larval sea lamprey from streams and deltas to determine the presence and density of sea lamprey populations. This information is used to determine which streams or deltas are in need of control measures and which control measures to use.

Scientists and fish managers continue to consider, other methods to reduce sea lamprey impacts. These include the use of pheromones (chemical attractants naturally produced by lamprey) to capture adult sea lamprey, the release of sterile males to disrupt spawning, and the stocking of lamprey-resistant strains of fish.

.

More about Sea Lamprey:

  • Sea Lamprey Events – Schedule and announcements of treatments and other events related to sea lamprey control on Lake Champlain
  • Sea Lamprey Experts – Experts on Lake Champlain sea lamprey discuss the natural history and past, current, & future control efforts

The post Sea Lamprey in Lake Champlain appeared first on Lake Champlain Life.

Have You Signed the Petition to Close The Champlain Canal Yet?

Join Over 500 Other Friends of Lake Champlain

Please Sign The Petition to Close the Champlain Canal!

 

Petition to Close The Champlain Canal

Spiny Water flea

The Champlain Canal is a 60-mile long canal that connects Lake Champlain with the Hudson river.  At its peak, it was used by thousands of people to transport goods and for transportation. Today the canal is used mostly by recreational boaters and some commercial vessels.Approximately 20 invasive species have already been introduced to Lake Champlain through the canal, and the spiny water flea threatens to be the next invasive species that invades Lake Champlain. Like other lakes in the U.S., the Lake Champlain ecosystem, including fish and wildlife, and the surrounding economy will be significantly compromised with the invasion of the spiny water flea.  It is estimated that the total annual cost of invasive species linked to the canal is nearly $500 million (Pimentel, 2005; http://bit.ly/Ozpywt), clearly illustrating the economic importance of disconnecting the canal from Lake Champlain.  With 5,000 pleasure boats using the canal each year (Dan Weiller, spokesman for the NY State Canal Corp), it costs $100,000 of public funds per boat to keep the canal open.Numerous options exist to close the canal while accommodating boat traffic. Funding has already been set aside to cover the costs of closing the canal.

Please sign and share this petition to protect Lake Champlain and the regional economy from destructive invasive species.

You can learn more about the effort to disconnect the canal here: http://bit.ly/ChampCanal

You can also read “Feasibility of Champlain Canal Aquatic Nuisance Species Barrier Options” for suggested solutions on how to close the canal:http://www.uvm.edu:8889/~seagrant/communications/assets/ansbarrierrprt06.pdf

The post Have You Signed the Petition to Close The Champlain Canal Yet? appeared first on Lake Champlain Life.

Are Lampreys an Invasive Species?

Sea lamprey illustration. The original caption...

Sea lamprey illustration. The original caption read: Fig. 586.–Petromyzon marinus, sea lamprey. (After Goode.) (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Invasive species are plants or animals that are not native to an area, and when introduced become a problem to the original ecosystem. Sea lampreys have been causing some problems in Lake Champlain, but are they invaders or simply a species that has grown out of control?There is some debate about the origins of the sea lamprey in Lake Champlain. Some call them invasive species, but recently there have been discoveries that may point to this disliked species being more local than previously thought.

Let’s Look at the Evidence

Is the sea lamprey invasive species? It had long been believed that the lamprey had entered “Lake Champlain via the Champlain Canal, the Richelieu River and Canal, and over land primarily through human activities such as boating and bait transport” (Lake Champlain Basin Program).

“The sea lamprey was first noted in Lake Champlain in 1929 by J.R. Greeley, who reported that sea lamprey were found in moderate numbers at that time. It is not clear if, or for how long, sea lamprey had existed in Lake Champlain prior to this time.” (NYDEC)

English: Sea lamprey wounds (Petromyzon marinu...Sea lamprey wounds (Petromyzon marinus) on a salmon (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

If we take into account that fishing was a major source of food for settlers and natives at the time, and also consider the fact that sea lampreys leave obvious signs of their presence on the local fish – wounds, scars, and attached lamprey – “the lack of mention of lamprey in the oral and written history is consistent with the position that sea lamprey may be a non-native invasive species.” (NYDEC)

New Evidence Points to Native

Despite this long-held believe, recent genetic studies indicate that the sea lamprey may actually be native to Lake Champlain (NYDEC).

Some people now believe that the sea lamprey may be a native species leftover from the Champlain Sea  (Lake Champlain Basin Program). If this is true, then why have sea lampreys only recently begun to cause problems?

It may be because of:

  1. “The change in human use of the lands and waters in the lake’s watershed may have resulted in increased habitat for larval lamprey” (NYDEC).
  2. Also the original Lake Champlain salmon and trout have died out and the foreign strains introduced to stock the lake did not evolve with lamprey, therefore these fish may be more susceptible to sea lamprey parasitism (NYDEC).

Does their origin matter?

Do the lampreys have a right to be in Lake Champlain if they are native?

Native or non-native, are sea lampreys in Lake Champlain causing a major problem? Some believe that if left unchecked other fish populations would be seriously impacted as the parasitic sea lampreys feed on and kill other species–many of which are sought after by anglers.

Sunset on Lake Champlain, taken from hotel win...Lake Champlain (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Organizations from New York and Vermont have collaborated to create a lamprey control program. The program is not trying to exterminate the lampreys, but is trying manage them.

Some environmentalists are concerned that the methods used to control the lampreys are damaging to the ecology of the lake. Some others consider the freedom of the lake’s various species to be greater than the need to for the lake to be an angler’s tourist destination.

What is your opinion?

Related articles

The post Are Lampreys an Invasive Species? appeared first on Essex on Lake Champlain.